Inbox: Who will comprise Phils’ 2017 OF?

Who do you think starts in the Phillies’ outfield on Opening Day? Odubel Herrera? Roman Quinn? Aaron Altherr? Nick Williams? — Brian S., Clearwater, Fla.

This is a tough question to answer, because the offseason hasn’t started yet. Everybody knows Phillies manager Pete Mackanin wants at least one hitter with a proven track record to be added to next season’s lineup. After all, the Phillies ranked last in baseball with 610 runs.

I believe the Phillies will acquire an outfielder, but I’m not sure it will be somebody like Ian Desmond, who will require a lucrative, multi-year contract. That said, if I had to guess today, I would say Herrera is the only lock. Quinn showed flashes of brilliance in September, but he also needs polish. Altherr did not fare well returning from wrist surgery, but a strong spring could change the team’s feelings about him. Williams faded hard in August, so I’ve got to think he will open the season in Triple-A.

• Submit a question to the Phillies Inbox

Will the Phillies trade Cameron Rupp this offseason? — Dennis M., Ruidoso, N.M.

Believe it or not, I get asked this question a lot. Do people assume Jorge Alfaro or Andrew Knapp are guaranteed to become superstars? I’m not sure why people think that way, considering “can’t miss” prospects don’t always meet expectations. Personally, I don’t see the Phillies trading Rupp this winter, unless they get an offer they can’t refuse, because he is the only proven catcher in the organization. Despite late-season struggles, Rupp ranked eighth out of 19 qualified catchers with a .752 OPS. Alfaro and Knapp have potential, but they haven’t done it yet. Rupp has.

Is there any consideration of trying to resign Ryan Howard at less than the $23 million? — Jeff M., Warminster, Pa.

The ceremony for Howard on the final day of the …

continue reading in source mlb.mlb.com